An Impending GOP ‘Civil War?’

Don Walton today:

So what happens now?

Bruning launches his “ground game,” identifying and organizing supporters across the state.

And he begins the rather challenging task of attempting to raise funds for a campaign he may never wage.

Hagel loyalists in the Republican ranks are going to hold tight, one would guess.

Bruning loyalists will step forward behind their man.

And what will Republicans who are angry with Hagel for opposing President Bush on Iraq do?

Judging by letters to the editor, telephone messages and anecdotal evidence, there are a lot of them out there. They are upset, and they are energized.

If you paid attention to last year’s Republican gubernatorial primary, it revealed a very real split within the Nebraska Republican Party. It’s hard to pinpoint any ideological lines for the split – it seems more of a clash of personalities, a party establishment against those who find themselves on the outside. Almost a cult of personality centered around Chuck Hagel. There is certainly ample evidence that Hagel can hold a grudge and that Heineman has some of the same traits. So Jon Bruning didn’t exactly make any friends among the Nebraska Republican kingmakers by endorsing Tom Osborne for governor.

The Osborne/Heineman race was odd in many ways, in that the arguably more “moderate” but decidedly more partisan Heineman was at once both the establishment candidate and the anti-Osborne candidate. It’s still difficult to quite understand what the coalition of voters was that ultimately won the race for Heineman, but it’s hard to argue against the fact that Hagel’s endorsement carried a lot of weight – giving his campaign legitimacy when it wasn’t at all clear that he could run and make it competitive, let alone win. This was, after all, an unelected governor.

The strange alliances that followed in this race, the issues that came up, are hard to explain, difficult to understand out of context. Strong progressive Democrats like Gwen Howard endorsed Tom Osborne for Governor. Two conservative Democrats bolting the party to endorse Dave Heineman. Ultra-right wing Republican Kate Witek jumping ship to the Democratic Party because of Heineman.

In Hagel’s position, the alliances become even more bizarre. David Kramer, Dave Heineman, and Hal Daub all get up there on television and try to explain how Iraq could be a positive for Hagel – in a Republican primary. These are Republicans in a deeply Republican state. At least Adrian Smith doesn’t hide his right-wing rhetoric.

It still seems unlikely that Hagel will receive a challenge from Bruning – more likely that Johanns or some other Republican receives Hagel’s backing for an open seat. But if Hagel does decide to seek reelection, Bruning has an opening that wasn’t available to Tom Osborne. There wasn’t a significant amount of Republican displeasure with Dave Heineman. He had very high approval ratings throughout the election. But there is an energized and real portion of the Republican electorate that can’t stand Chuck Hagel. Whether that means that Bruning can overcome the significant disadvantages he would have against Hagel – like Osborne, Bruning has never faced a competitive race for elected office – is yet to be seen.

But we need to be better prepared to fight this race than we were in 2006. This means many things:

1.) Staying out of the Republicans’ fight. No “Republicans-for-a-day.”

2.) Getting a real candidate and supporting that candidate. Make it clear that the best choice in this election, no matter who the Republicans choose, is the Democrat.

3.) Don’t prematurely concede this race. Period.

Which is why this note from the same article bothers me:

Charlie Matulka, the 2002 Democratic Senate nominee, says he’s ready to challenge Hagel again in 2008 and “demand a statewide handcount” of the vote.

Matulka lost in 2002 83-17%, and subsequently engaged in wild conspiracy theories accusing Chuck Hagel of rigging the election. In 2006, he lost a race for Public Service Commissioner 61-39%. It does not appear that he accused Frank Landis of stealing that election. The integrity of our elections is indeed a very real issue, and we must safeguard our democracy. But throwing out baseless accusations hurts the entire cause. There have been very real problems with voting machines across the country, and Hagel’s connection to ES&S raises some ethical questions. But there is not a shred of evidence that suggests his victory in 1996 was illegitimate, and to suggest that Hagel did not win legitimately in 2002 strains the credibility of everyone involved.

There is an opportunity here, with a fractured Republican Party, to make some inroads and put up a real candidate that can win. But we need to take ourselves seriously as a party. We have to make a real effort. 2002 was a disaster on all levels for this party – we can’t allow that to happen again.

2 Responses to “An Impending GOP ‘Civil War?’”


  1. 1 john Mar 20th, 2007 at 12:20 am

    Dave:
    A key issue of the Hagel endorsement is the fact that Hagel preemptivley endorsed Heiny; that is, he made the endorsement well before Osborne got in the race.

    The speculation then is, and I think I agree, that Hagel was trying to push Osborne into the race against Nelson, because he thought Osborne was the only one who could beat Nelson (besides Johanns who had just taken a pass)- and Hagel would like nothing more than to get rid of Nelson, who he hates.

  2. 2 dave Mar 20th, 2007 at 8:02 am

    Yeah, but I think everybody assumed at that point that Osborne was running for Governor. It was a preemptive endorsement – and a slight to Osborne as well. In a lot of ways, Bruning’s gambit here is similar. It’s certainly poking Hagel in the eye a bit right after his “announcement.” He sets himself up as the frontrunner. One problem though: he’s managed to alienate just about every other elected Republican in the state. If he doesn’t win the nomination, he’s finished.

    This has the potential to be a bloody primary fight. Grab some popcorn and enjoy.

Leave a Reply

You must login to post a comment.





cheap flights cheap flights athens greece phoenix2c arizona2c usa zoom cheap flights cheap flights to canada cheap flights from london cheap flights london cheap flights to bermuda cheap flights hamilton bermuda cheap flights edmonton cheap flights to cheap flights to london uk cheap flights to england cheap uk flights cheap london flights book cheap flights cheap discount flights cheap flights bermuda international cheap flights manchester cheap flights com cheap flights bermuda cheap flights glasgow cheap flights to london cheap air flights cheap flights to capetown from uk cheap flights uk cheap flights to new york cheap international flights cheap flights to the canaries very cheap international flights cheap flights to alicante cheap flights to australia cheap flights to florida cheap flights to greece cheap flights from edinburgh cheap flights to india cheap flights leeds bradford cheap last minute flights cheap flights from belfast cheap flights almeria cheap flights newcastle cheap flights alicante cheap flights to south africa cheap flights cyprus cheap flights greece cheap flights from leeds bradford cheap flights to toronto cheap flights corfu cheap flights to malta cheap flights to almeria cheap flights rhodes cheap internal flights uk cheap flights madrid cheap flights to corfu cheap flights blackpool seoul air fares cheap flights to seoul south korea at airfares cheap flights to rhodes cheap flights to chambery cheap flights to italy cheap flights to scotland cheap flights from blackpool cheap flights malaga cheap flights to france cheap flights in australia cheap flights sardinia cheap flights to bangkok cheap flights to lisbon cheap europe flights flights cheap cheap flights chambery cheap flights cardiff cheap flights usa cheap flights from belfast to malaga cheap flights to ireland cheap flights from newcastle cheap flights uk to spain cheap flights to almeria spain cheap uk domestic flights cheap flights paphos cheap flights krakow belarus ind cheap flights cheap flights asia cheap flights to cape town cheap flights to melbourne australia cheap flights uk australia cheap flights ireland singapore cheap flights canada cheap round the world flights cheap flights london barcelona cheap flights from edinburgh to birhamgan cheap flights to barcelona cheap flights to lanzarote really cheap flights cheap flights belfast london cheap flights to palma cheap flights to menorca cheap flights to dubai cheap flights kansai airport guangzhou cheap flights to boadaux france cheap australian flights cheap flights singapore phuket cheap flights alicante london cheap flights singapore phuket cheap flights to portugal cheap flights brisbane to townsville super cheap flights to polnd cheap one way flights flights usa cheap cheap flights china cheap flights to usa las vegas angola ind cheap flights cheap flights from taiwan cheap flights to fort lauderdale cheap flights to netherlands cheap flights to bakersfield bangladesh ind cheap flights cheap flights to myrtle beach cheap flights to philippines belize ind cheap flights cheap flights to malaysia cheap internal flights in the usa cheap flights from phoenix to hawaii cheap flights dublin to london cheap flights london tel aviv cheap vegas flights cheap flights from minneapolis to canada antigua and ind cheap flights cheap flights from malaga to london bahamas ind cheap flights cheap flights jersey cheap flights spain cheap flights to jamaica cheap last minute flights to london cheap flights menorca eastjet cheap flights bahrain ind cheap flights cheap flights manilla to singapore cheap flights to madrid cheap flights to egypt cheap flights to hawaii cheap flights to las vegas from cardiff cheap flights birmingham to malaga cheap flights to africa cheap flights orlando cheap flights to murcia cheap flights to vienna cheap flights to galway cheap flights to hurghada cheap flights bangkok cheap flights barcelona cheap flights tenerife cheap flights to california cheap flights from leeds cheap flights to europe bhutan ind cheap flights cheap flights to melbourne cheap flights from edinburgh to malaga cheap air flights in europe cheap flights online usa barbados ind cheap flights cheap flights to cancun cheap flights from dublin cheap flights fiji cheap flights to bulgaria from uk cheap flights from leeds bradford airport cheap flights to bodrum find cheap flights argentina ind cheap flights cheap flights uk cheap flights finder cheap flights to antigua cheap flights to usa ba cheap flights new zealand cheap flights to trinidad cheap new zealand flights cheap flights london brussels cheap flights heathrow barcelona cheap flights from poland usa jersy to london cheap flights cheap flights to frankfurt cheap flights to spain europe cheap flights to perth australia cheap bahama all inclusive vacation packages plus flights cheap aerlinmgus flights to dublin cheap air flights to spain cheap flights nashville to las vegas cheap international flights europe north america cheap flights from texas to florida cheap flights bristol cheap flights from boston usa to dublin cheap domestic flights cheap charter flights cheap flights hkg lhr hkg cheap flights from portugal to spain cheap flights to usa panama cheap one way domestic flights discount travel cheap flights from canada to mexico asian cheap flights cheap flights singapore bangkok cheap flights international cheap flights seville spain to paris france cheap flights leaving form toronto canada cheap flights vietnam cheap flights to miami germany cheap tickets to las vegas cheap flights to mexico cheap flights to uk cheap flights for students cheap flights brisbane to melbourne cheap flights to us cheap flights to trinidad from ny cheap flights to seattle cheap flights to bali cheap flights to jersey easyjet cheap flights cheap flights east midlands malaga cheap flights to puerto v cheap flights thailand cheap flights to mexico cheap flights from southhampton to edinburgh cheap flights to mississippi cheap flights to sao paulo amsterdam cheap flights cheap flights to las vegas from london uk cheap asia flights paris cheap usa flights cheap flights to austin texas usa cheap flights las vegas emergency cheap usa flights cheap flights from newcastle to gatwick cheap flights to fuerteventura cheap flights to sydney australia cheap airline flights to fl cheap flights from florida to aluthra in the baham cheap flights to venice cheap flights one way to orlando florida cheap flights last minute air travel cheap flights and hotels